restaurant chef preparing a dish
October 17, 2023

9 Can’t-Miss Restaurants in Middletown, DE

Are you in search of some of the most mouthwatering restaurants in Middletown, DE

Middletown is located near both the family-friendly areas of Newark and Wilmington, and its food scene is growing as quickly as its residential properties and population.

This can make it difficult to choose which restaurants in Middletown, DE, to go for a night out or to even get takeaway. Don’t worry, though — we’ve curated a list of the top 9 Middletown restaurants that you won’t want to miss out on.

Find your next family dinner, social outing, or date night below.

1. 1861 Southern Kitchen Bourbon Bar🥃

If you’re looking for a more contemporary dining experience with influences from Middletown’s rich history, 1861 Southern Kitchen Bourbon Bar is the gastropub to visit. Here you’ll find a straightforward menu that doesn’t skimp on the flavor with their buttery seared scallops, juicy burgers, upscale pizzas, local wines, craft beers, and elegant cocktails. Dress up or dress down — it’s a great choice for a date or a night out with friends.

Address: 423 N Broad St, Middletown, DE 19709

Phone: (302) 376-7965

2. Sushi Yama 🍣

Sushi lovers of Middletown rejoice — Sushi Yama is where you want to go for an elegant yet cozy dinner filled with fresh sushi roll spreads, inspiring art, great service, and tons of color. The chef at Sushi Yama is well known for creating sushi plates that make every last customer gasp in excitement, and that includes the very popular plates with the Monster and Mexican Rolls.

Address: 572 W Main St, Middletown, DE 19709

Phone: (302) 376-8680

3. Tom Foolery’s Restaurant & Bar 🍻

Looking for a spacious spot to watch the game? Tom Foolery’s Restaurant & Bar can accommodate you and the whole family or all your friends. Tom Foolery’s is one of the best restaurants around, and here you’ll find classic American food in a very playful atmosphere (hence the name). They also serve very large portions at cheap prices with tons of daily specials that’ll keep you coming back for more. This place will easily become one of your regular haunts as far as restaurants in Middletown, DE, go!

Address: 714 Ash Blvd, Middletown, DE 19709

Phone: (302) 449-221

4. Los Machados Mexican Restaurant 🌮

Los Machadoes is a highly-rated and family-friendly Mexican restaurant serving up all the fresh Mexican classics you can imagine. The shrimp enchiladas are a big hit here, and there are plenty of plant-based dishes to accommodate your vegan and vegetarian friends. With vibrant and colorful decor and some of the best margarita specials in town, you really can’t go wrong when you’re cravings take you south of the border. 

Address: 600 N Broad St, Middletown, DE 19709

Phone: (302) 378-1677

5. La Banca 🍝

When you want classic Italian cuisine with a slight yet unique twist, La Banca is the perfect place. La Banca is considered upscale casual, which makes it perfect for special occasions or a date you want to impress. The bolognese sauce here has received tons of rave reviews, as has the gelato and freshly made craft cocktails. They also have a singer on most nights to add to the romantic ambiance.

Address: 1 W Main St, Middletown, DE 19709

Phone: (302) 570-7600

6. Curry & Spice Bar 🍛

If you’re craving Indian cuisine, the Curry & Spice Bar will hit the spot every time. This family-owned restaurant offers up a full menu of classic Indian dishes you’d find in places like Punjab and the villages of Gujarat. However, they add a modern twist to the menu by adding fusion dishes like the aloo tikki burger and modern refreshing cocktails. The ambiance is inspired by the fields and villages of the owners’ homeland, and it’ll transport you to India through its decor, flavors, and aromas.

Address: 814 Kohl Ave, Middletown, DE 19709

Phone: (302) 696-2103

7. Metro Diner 🥞

Everyone needs a go-to diner in their lives, especially when it comes to great food (especially breakfast) — and the Metro Diner will serve just that. The award-winning comfort food diner serves up all the classic American fairies from pancakes to burgers, but they don’t skimp on the fun stuff like fried chicken and waffles either. The menu is incredibly diverse to suit a wide range of tastes, and they serve breakfast all day long. The only downside is that the diner is always pretty busy, so you may have to wait a while for a table.

Address: 745 Middletown Warwick Rd, Middletown, DE 19709

Phone: (302) 3314-3838

8. Sully’s Irish Pub 🇮🇪

Sullys Irish Pub is truly a treat as it’s everything you’d expect from an Irish pub — a dark-lit one-room tavern with tons of Irish and local town history. In fact, it’s Delaware’s oldest bar — and you can tell by the decor. The tavern first opened in 1761, and the decor hasn’t changed too much since. Here you can enjoy a great menu (which is a bit more modern than the bar itself) and eat and drink where Goerge Washington and Thomas Jefferson once did. Cheers!

Address: 12 W Main St, Middletown, DE 19709

Phone: (302) 376-8222

9. Stoltzfus BBQ 🥩

If you have a hankering for fresh BBQ — emphasis on the fresh — you won’t want to bypass Stoltzfus BBQ. This BBQ joint serves up 100% fresh, all-natural faire, sans hormones and antibiotics. You’ll find up to 10 different flavors of wings, homemade chicken pot pies, smoked ribs, and much, much more here. You can even order uncooked or prepared rotisserie-style foods to take home and catering services, and Stoltzfus doubles as a deli!

Address: 701 N Broad St, Middletown, DE 19709

Phone: (302) 285-0866

Support Local in Middletown

Your options for high-quality dining experiences are endless when it comes to restaurants in Middletown, DE. You can find every type of food from around the world here, plus plenty of history to surround you while you eat. 

While you’re out and about enjoying all the delicious food that Middletown has to offer, allow us to update your home. Are you ready to enjoy summer with a brand new or upgraded deck, a new addition, a porch, or more?

Get in touch with us here at Sundance Kitchen, Baths & Exteriors to learn more about our renovation services, and schedule your free consultation today!

Let’s make your dream home a reality.

Get In Touch